The White Painting
What it took me to understand in front of an empty canvas at the Tate Modern
A few years ago I was in London. A meeting had ended and the next one was still hours away. I had nothing planned and I was near the Tate Modern, so I went in to kill time.
I wandered through the galleries without hurrying until, in one of the rooms, I found myself in front of something that left me completely baffled.
It was a painting roughly a meter by a meter. Framed, lit and displayed with all the solemnity of a great work of art.
But the painting was white.
Completely white.
I stepped closer. I looked at it head on. Then from the side. I backed up a few paces. I came closer again. I even took photographs and zoomed in on my phone, thinking there might be some texture, a shadow, some detail I could not make out.
Nothing.
It was, at least to my eyes, a canvas painted uniformly white.
Then came that easy irony that shows up whenever we do not understand something.
I thought:
—What is so special about this? I could do this myself.
And not just a white one. I could paint a red one, a blue one, a black one, and present an entire collection.
Then I started questioning the museum's curator. Being a curator at the Tate Modern must be one of the most prestigious and sought-after positions in the art world. What could someone that qualified have seen, to decide that this white canvas deserved a wall in one of the most important museums in the world?
I left without an answer.
A few months later I went to a dinner. By chance I was seated next to a well-known art dealer, someone with galleries and offices in several countries and a great deal of experience in that world.
At some point in the conversation I remembered the white painting.
I told him the whole story: my bewilderment, the photographs, my doubts about the curator and, of course, my conclusion that I could have painted something similar myself.
He listened carefully and then said:
—I understand perfectly what you thought. But there is a fundamental difference between the painter of that work and you.
He paused and went on:
—He did it first. It occurred to him. It did not occur to you.
The answer hit me immediately.
He added:
—Now you could paint a white canvas, a red one, a green one or a blue one. But you would no longer be creating the idea. You would be reproducing something somebody else had the courage to imagine and present before you. The curator did not reward the execution alone. He rewarded the originality.
Right then I felt fairly ridiculous.
I had judged the work solely by how hard it looked to make. Because it seemed easy to execute, I had concluded it had no value.
But I was confusing two completely different things: being able to make something and being able to conceive it.
That confusion does not stay in museums.
I have seen it in dozens of businesses.
Someone adds up what it cost to make something. The materials, the hours, the salaries. Adds a percentage. And announces that number as if it were a price.
But that number is not a price.
It is a confession of how much work it took.
And the customer has no interest in how much work it took.
Nobody buys a white painting for the price of the canvas.
Nobody buys a book for the price of the paper.
Nobody picks a restaurant for the price of the tomatoes.
I had stood in front of that work doing exactly that arithmetic. I looked at the canvas, I calculated the labor and I passed sentence.
The dealer did not correct my taste. He corrected my arithmetic.
A great many creations look obvious once somebody has made them. A song, a company, an advertising campaign, a sentence, a piece of technology, even a simple white painting can provoke the same reaction:
"I could have done that too."
Maybe.
But we did not.
Somebody imagined it first, dared to execute it and accepted the risk that nobody would understand.
Since that conversation, the way I look at other people's creations has changed. Before reaching for irony or contempt, I try to ask myself a more honest question:
What did this person see before anyone else?
Because creating is not always a matter of making something complex.
Sometimes it is a matter of seeing what nobody had seen yet, having the courage to do it first, and putting up with everyone deciding, once it is done, that it was obvious.