Skip to content
Ariel Pfeffer

The Question From My Cousin That Would Have Saved Me a Fortune

A true story about how a great idea can turn into a terrible business

6 min read

In 2017 I had an idea that struck me as extraordinary.

And that was my first problem.

The idea was called Sharp Flight and, whenever I described it, it sounded so good to me that I could not understand how nobody had thought of it before.

Picture this.

You have to fly to New York. Your flight leaves at eight in the morning. And, as has happened to all of us at some point, you get to the airport, check your bag, go through security, buy a coffee that costs more than lunch and then, up on the screen, the word nobody wants to see appears:

DELAYED.

Your flight is late.

And then the ritual begins. You check the screen every five minutes, you ask at the counter, nobody knows anything, they tell you to wait, and you start calculating how many meetings you are going to lose, who is going to pick you up and how much of your life you are about to hand over to an airline.

Well, my idea was that at least somebody should pay you for the aggravation.

Before leaving home, you opened an app on your phone and bought a small policy.

You could choose: if your flight was delayed more than thirty minutes, you collected a certain amount. More than an hour, another. If you wanted to cover yourself for two hours, you could do that too.

All online. In seconds.

And the best part came afterward.

If the flight was delayed, the money appeared in your account automatically.

No claim to file.

No form to fill out.

No certificate from the airline.

No calling a number where a recording assures you that your call is very important while it plays you music for forty minutes.

Nothing.

The flight was late. You got paid.

Done.

To me it seemed brilliant.

There was also something technically very interesting about it.

Back then I was fascinated by what are known as oracles, which, put simply, are mechanisms that verify an event in the real world and use that information to execute an operation automatically.

In this case it was perfect.

Because there was no possible argument.

A flight had a scheduled departure time and an actual departure time. The same for arrivals. That information could be obtained from independent sources.

Nothing to interpret. Nobody to argue with. No adjuster weighing up how much you had suffered waiting at the airport.

Either it was delayed or it was not.

And if it was delayed longer than what you had bought, you got paid.

Naturally, we had to keep the thing from turning into an airborne casino. So you could only insure a flight you were actually taking, and you had to buy the coverage before any information existed that might anticipate a delay.

I could not insure the flight of some gentleman travelling from Singapore to London whom I had never met.

You had to prove you were a passenger.

Everything had a solution.

Or so I believed.

So I started moving forward.

Technical development, analysis of the model, system architecture, conversations, meetings...

And then the lawyers arrived.

American lawyers.

The kind who, when they send you an invoice, make you wonder whether it would have been cheaper to buy an airline outright.

Because there was one small inconvenience.

The United States has fifty states. And selling insurance is not exactly like selling T-shirts.

Each state has its own regulations, requirements and procedures. Depending on how the business was structured, it could need authorizations, licenses and specific agreements in multiple jurisdictions.

All of a sudden, that app the customer was going to use in twenty seconds was turning into a legal project that could take years and cost a fortune.

But I kept going.

Because I was convinced the idea was extraordinary.

And when you are convinced you have an extraordinary idea, you start developing an extremely dangerous skill:

The ability to find a solution to every problem except the one that actually matters.

I was debating how to automate the payment, how to verify the flights, how to prevent fraud, how to resolve the licensing, how to simplify the purchase.

I had answers for almost everything.

Until one day, talking with a cousin, I started telling him about the project.

I explained the insurance, the technology, the flights, the automatic payments, the oracles, the regulations...

I was excited.

And my cousin, who was listening perfectly calmly, asked me a question.

One question.

—Ariel, do people want to buy that?

I kept explaining.

—No, look, the interesting part is that the payment is automatic, you do not have to file anything, the system verifies the flights...

And he pressed.

—Yes, yes, I understand. But are there people who actually want to pay for it?

Silence.

Because that question, which seemed so elementary, was the only one I had not answered.

I had researched how to build the business.

I had researched how to make it work.

I had researched how to make it legal.

But I had not researched carefully enough whether anyone wanted to buy it.

And, worse still, whether there were enough people willing to pay for it to turn it into a profitable business.

So I started studying that question.

And what I found was fairly discouraging.

There was no significant unmet demand.

Of course, nobody likes a delayed plane. But one thing is being annoyed by something, and quite another is being willing to pay to protect yourself from the annoyance.

Everyone would prefer to collect money when a flight is delayed.

That does not mean everyone wants to buy delay insurance.

And that difference, which looks insignificant, is the difference between an interesting idea and a business.

There were people who might find the product attractive, naturally. But I had not identified a market large enough, with a desire strong enough and a willingness to pay clear enough.

Nor had I worked out how to create that desire at scale.

So Sharp Flight never became the business I had imagined.

And I lost the money I had invested.

But, in hindsight, the money was not the most important thing I lost.

The most important thing was discovering how much time I had spent answering questions nobody had asked me.

Because I had fallen in love.

Not with a woman.

Not with a city.

Not even with a business.

I had fallen in love with my own product.

And when you fall in love with your product you start justifying everything.

If the technology is complicated, we will solve it.

If the regulation is difficult, we will hire lawyers.

If the development is expensive, we will find investors.

If there are obstacles, we will overcome them.

All of that can be admirable.

But there is one question that no amount of enthusiasm, technology, lawyers or investors can replace:

Who wants to buy this, why do they want it, and how much are they willing to pay?

Over the years I discovered that I did not make this mistake only with Sharp Flight.

I repeated it several times.

With other projects, other ideas and other opportunities.

Because I have a tendency that can be a virtue and a flaw at the same time: imagining things that do not exist yet excites me.

And that is wonderful for creating.

But it can be disastrous for investing.

Creativity lets you imagine what could exist.

The market tells you whether anybody actually wants it.

And they are not necessarily the same thing.

So ever since, I try to remember something that cousin taught me with a question that cost him nothing at all.

While I had spent a fortune trying to answer how to make Sharp Flight work, he had reached the real problem in under thirty seconds.

And there is the lesson I would like to leave.

It is not enough for an idea to be intelligent.

It is not enough for it to be technically possible.

It is not enough for it to be distinctive, original or elegant.

It is not even enough for it to solve a real problem.

It has to solve a problem that enough people want solved, and are willing to pay to have solved.

And if that desire does not exist yet, it is worth knowing whether we are capable of creating it before spending a fortune trying to satisfy it.

Because, in the end, there is something worse than having a bad idea.

It is having an idea so good, so clever and so fascinating that it stops you from seeing that nobody is waiting for you to put it into practice.

Sharp Flight taught me that you can build a perfect solution for a demand that barely exists.

And that before asking yourself how you are going to build something, it is worth asking who is going to want to buy it.

Or, put another way:

Do not confuse the excitement you get from creating something with the desire that something arouses in other people.

Because your excitement is paid for by you.

But a business only exists when somebody else is willing to pay for it.

Other columns

  • The White Painting

    What it took me to understand in front of an empty canvas at the Tate Modern

The autopsies, first in your inbox.

Every new autopsy reaches the list first: the short version, the key finding and a few extra things I don't publish anywhere. No spam, no discounts, no "last chance".

You can unsubscribe anytime, with one click, no hard feelings.

Get the autopsies